Animation quality: Easy guide to evaluate great animated learning videos
What is this animation quality guide about?
It is not easy to tell the animation quality of different types, especially if you are not some insider in the animation industry but an absolutely clueless instructional designer or educator.
Yeah, the high-quality animation is not that hard to spot, you may say! If you think animations by Walt Disney or DreamWorks are amazing, you are right! However, let’s be real. Those Incredibles are millions of dollar investment. Hence you could hardly reach such quality without an enormous budget. But we do not need “Cartoon Network” standard to create beautiful and yet effective educational animations. The main propose of animated learning video is to deliver the knowledge in a clear and engaging way. Sparkles or unicorns may come as unnecessary (unless you are building an online course on Defense Against the Dark Arts for Hogwarts).
Then if the standard is not “Cartoon Network”, then how can we identify a good 2D animation?
In this article, we would guide you through:
- What makes an animated learning video?
- 4 common types of 2D animation in the eLearning industry
- How to tell the quality of different animations
I hope you would learn valuable insights to make the right decision for your budget. Then you would have more explicit expectations as well as requirements for effective partnership with an animation studio.
What makes an animated learning video?
Firstly, before we start, you have to understand what animated learning videos are and how they actually differ from advertisements and animated movies.
- Animated learning videos serve as an educational purpose, conveying information to a wide variety of audiences. An advertisement, on the other hand, tries to promote a product to a target audience, whereas a movie tells a story while focusing on its theme and meaning rather than educating.
- Animated learning videos don’t require twists and complex plots like the other 2. This genre’s selling point doesn’t lie in its wow factor, but its educational values.
- The visuals in an educational animation are subpar compared to the other 2. All an animator needs to do is make it appealing enough to support the massive load of information it offers.
Different types of 2D educational animations
Before we jump off to the technical details of animations, you must understand that different types of animations have different standards. You cannot judge a whiteboard animated video is poor in quality due to the lack of details it has. Whiteboard animations could engage learners as sophisticated hand-drawn animations do. As long as the videos stay consistent with the learning objectives, any types of animations would benefit the learning outcomes.
There are various types of animations in this digital world. You may have seen some of these common types:
2D animated cartoons
2D animated cartoons are those you see on Ted-ed. They inherit the techniques of traditional hand-drawn animations, which means the animators would have to draw every frame to illustrate the movements. Although technology has reduced the animators’ workload, 2D cartoons are time-consuming. The artists still have to proceed frame-by-frame then. The great effort, on the other hand, results in a smooth and dimensional work of animation.
Motion graphics appear everywhere in TV commercials, explainer videos, and of course, educational videos. Motion graphics are much different from 2D animated cartoons. The animators don’t necessarily understand the body mechanics of acting, composition or camera motion. They may not bother drawing 15-24 frames per second. In fact, the artists use software like Adobe After Effect to animate elements on the screen: objects, text, and characters.
Motion graphics hence are less dimensional than 2D animated cartoons. Most animation elements stay in the flat environment since the movements are generated from the software.
Stop-motions is not the most popular in the animation world. They are somewhat like 2D animated cartoons. To give the illusion of movements, the artists take a photo of an object then another shot of it moving a little bit. However, the difference is they require the animators to set up the objects, characters, and backgrounds in the real environment rather than the digital workspace. Stop-motions hence are time-consuming and difficult to express complicated concepts.
If you have seen those famous YouTube videos by ASAP Science, you must have acknowledged what whiteboard animations look like. Basically, the videos present a hand drawing on board with text and audio narration. The details are minimalized to strengthen the storytelling. And yes, the essential part of whiteboard animations is storytelling. The design is pure doodles on board, so simple that one with no animation background could create this type of video. A more advanced version of whiteboard animated videos includes more color and movements to enhance the uniqueness and interaction.
Animation Quality Guide: What makes a GOOD animated learning video?
Now that you’ve understood what animated learning videos are, it’s time to take it up a notch. There are mainly 3 aspects to judge animation quality, and for each of them, we will provide you with a few key questions that you need to ask yourself every time you’re producing one.
Sign up for free to read the rest of the guide.
A script is the spine of the video. It shows how well the story is developed and later told. A good scriptwriter could transform your ideas, even just a fraction of the learning theory, into something engaging to learners.
In fact, writing a script for educational purposes is really challenging. For example, explaining how the heart pumps require lots of mind-blowing medical specialized words. To make it informational is no big deal, but the tricky part is making it funny and interesting enough to keep the audience engaged. You definitely don’t want to make it just another boring lecture!
A good script should convey the concepts to the fullest while maintaining the balance between entertainment and information. Furthermore, good storytelling also plays a vital role since it keeps students focused and engaged in the learning process.
Here are a few questions you can ask yourself to make sure your script is good:
Is the plot relatable and relevant to the learning materials?
Does the script explain the learning concepts to the fullest?
Is the story straight-forward with well highlighted key points?
Is the flow natural with a conversational tone?
Do the characters have personalities that stay close to your students’ persona?
2. Visual design
The definition of “beautiful” depends on personal tastes. Your artwork may be breathtaking to some, but appear completely bland for another. Although art is subjective, there are some guidelines you can follow to make it as appealing as possible to your audience.
Art isn’t supposed to look nice; it’s supposed to make you feel something. The trick is to fish out emotions from your audience. Sometimes you have to put yourself in your audience’s shoes and meet their demands. It all comes down to what your audience wants.
This is what makes a tailor-made product stand out from one that’s made from a template. A high-quality animation knows best to follow the branding guideline closely to convey a sense of style and exclusivity. This imprints the design in the students’ brains, so everything becomes more memorable and unique.
That said, if originality isn’t your priority or you don’t have the resources to make it happen, you can use a cloud-based animation software instead. Such software provides a massive library of characters and background elements that can help you create a professional product. However, this is not a long-term solution since there will come a time when your work will demand more freedom.
To top it all off, here are some questions to ask yourself:
Is the visual design eye-catching and polished enough?
Does it fit your learners’ interests?
Does it stay consistent with your branding image and message?
Smooth. It has to be smooth. There is nothing that determines the quality of the animation more than smooth movements. The more technology is improved, the more viewers demand more from animation: they want reality. The best animation is one that captivates the fluid motions of real-life objects.
So how exactly does one make that happen?
In their book The Illustration of Life: Disney Animation, Disney animators Ollie Johnston and Frank Thomas explained the 12 principles of animation. The book is later deemed the animator’s Bible. So here is a short summary:
Even if you don’t have the budget or the time or plainly don’t prioritize that, try to learn from it as it will undoubtedly be beneficial to your future work.
And ask yourself this before finishing a product:
Does the movement look smooth and fluid?
What is your transition like?
Here are a few examples to demonstrate the differences between a proper animated educational video and one for entertainment.
This is one of our products at F. Learning Studio. Amidst all the panic about the pandemic, we decided to make a short video to help educate people and keep them calm. You can clearly see that there’s a consistent theme throughout the whole video, which our animators originally created. This conveys our originality to viewers. The script is strictly professional, but it’s still casual enough to appeal to a large number of viewers.
Here is an example of an animated short movie – it’s a personal favorite. You can clearly see the quality of the artwork, and if you’re willing enough to sit through it, you will find yourself drowning in emotions. And this short animation doesn’t even have any lines, it’s just a script with scenes and no dialogues.
Now you should have some clear directions on how to evaluate an animated learning video. Quality should always be your top priority, and since you are the one who decides that, it’s a plus when you have the essential knowledge. Another tip to create better products is to get more involved in the animating process’s pre-production steps. This will help the animators avoid many mistakes and significantly save you time.
When it comes to applying animation to an educational course, deciding on an animation budget is a difficult thing. If you've done your research, you probably noticed that animation studios often don't publish their pricing on websites. The reason is that...
Unlike the videos created for students or the general public, mental health educational videos for scientific explanations are more complicated and require more effort from the audiences to fully understand. These videos aim to shed some light on the issues of...
Mental health education for students has never been more urgent than now. With the rise of technology and social media, the new generation can face a lot of problematic issues at very young ages. But not like physical health, for which schools and families have...